Correct the Writing Desk model in both Minecraft 1.21.1 and 26.3, specifically the selected-page and paper-stack geometry/placement. This is a model-focused issue, as clarified by the user.
Scope:
Review the current model assets against references in dev images.
Correct page and paper-stack geometry, position, height, scale and orientation relative to the desk's writing surfaces.
Keep the paper white; arrange the paper stack on the right, slightly forward, and align the selected page with its intended surface.
Check the complete two-block model in all four horizontal orientations, avoiding clipping, floating geometry or overlap.
Coordinate renderer attachment offsets only where required to fit the corrected model; the model is the focus, not a GUI redesign.
Acceptance:
Comparison screenshots of the model for all four facings in both versions, with page only, paper only, both and neither, including low/full paper counts.
Displayed items stay aligned after selection/input changes and chunk reload/restart.
Neighboring block faces remain visible correctly around the model.
Page storage, copy costs and other desk behavior are outside this issue. The initial 26.3 desk port reuses 1.21.1 assets/offsets; that reuse is not evidence that the model placement is correct.
Correct the Writing Desk model in both Minecraft 1.21.1 and 26.3, specifically the selected-page and paper-stack geometry/placement. This is a model-focused issue, as clarified by the user.
Scope:
- Review the current model assets against references in dev images.
- Correct page and paper-stack geometry, position, height, scale and orientation relative to the desk's writing surfaces.
- Keep the paper white; arrange the paper stack on the right, slightly forward, and align the selected page with its intended surface.
- Check the complete two-block model in all four horizontal orientations, avoiding clipping, floating geometry or overlap.
- Coordinate renderer attachment offsets only where required to fit the corrected model; the model is the focus, not a GUI redesign.
Acceptance:
- Comparison screenshots of the model for all four facings in both versions, with page only, paper only, both and neither, including low/full paper counts.
- Displayed items stay aligned after selection/input changes and chunk reload/restart.
- Neighboring block faces remain visible correctly around the model.
Page storage, copy costs and other desk behavior are outside this issue. The initial 26.3 desk port reuses 1.21.1 assets/offsets; that reuse is not evidence that the model placement is correct.
dnorberg
added this to the Dual-version support milestone 2026-11-05 22:01:50 -05:00
dnorberg
changed title from Correct Writing Desk page and paper-stack placement (1.21.1 and 26.3) to Correct Writing Desk model: page and paper-stack placement (1.21.1 and 26.3)2026-11-05 22:03:44 -05:00
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
Correct the Writing Desk model in both Minecraft 1.21.1 and 26.3, specifically the selected-page and paper-stack geometry/placement. This is a model-focused issue, as clarified by the user.
Scope:
Acceptance:
Page storage, copy costs and other desk behavior are outside this issue. The initial 26.3 desk port reuses 1.21.1 assets/offsets; that reuse is not evidence that the model placement is correct.
Correct Writing Desk page and paper-stack placement (1.21.1 and 26.3)to Correct Writing Desk model: page and paper-stack placement (1.21.1 and 26.3)